TL;DR
In a Colorado mountain home featured on Fixer Upper, Chip and Joanna Gaines used chocolate-colored patterned clay tiles instead of subway tile in a game-room kitchen. The design ties the room to its mountain setting, while the handmade look comes with higher costs and installation considerations.
Chip and Joanna Gaines used chocolate-colored patterned clay tiles instead of subway tile in the game-room kitchen of a Colorado mountain home featured in Fixer Upper: Colorado Mountain House—Part 2. The choice reflects the renovation’s aim to draw on the surrounding landscape and create a warmer, more cottage-like space, according to the couple’s Magnolia blog post.
Get furniture and decor delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The selected tile is Tiles of Ezra Amano Caja in chocolate, described as a take on the Delft tile trend. Its ivory background and light-brown geometric pattern provide detail without the uniform glossy look associated with classic subway tile. The tiles appear in the home’s game-room kitchen area, including the backdrop for a hot cocoa and coffee bar mentioned in the episode.
The Gaineses said the Colorado project called for a departure from the modern farmhouse style associated with many of their earlier renovations. Their Magnolia blog described the design direction as European cottage-inspired colors, textures and patterns, intended to give the home an all-around cozy feel. The blog also said the tile was chosen to nod to the Rocky Mountains and blend with the surroundings.
The makeover is notable as the couple’s first renovation away from Texas, according to the episode description in the supplied material. The tile is one element of a broader design approach, rather than a standalone recommendation: the kitchen combines warm colors, patterned surfaces and rustic details to support the home’s mountain setting.
A warmer backsplash choice for a Colorado kitchen
Chip and Joanna Gaines used patterned chocolate clay tile in a mountain-home game-room kitchen. The choice ties the room to its setting and shows how a backsplash can shape a kitchen’s mood.
The tile choice
The patterned tile brings detail and warmth to a compact kitchen area.
Amano Caja in chocolate
Tiles of Ezra’s clay tile has an ivory base with a light-brown geometric pattern.
Game-room kitchen
It appears near the home’s hot cocoa and coffee bar.
European cottage feel
Warm colors, textures and patterns help the interior feel cozy and connected to the Rocky Mountains.
A different backsplash mood
The example is a specific design choice, not proof that subway tile has fallen out of favor.
- Crafted look with visible variation
- Adds warmth and visual detail
- Costs and installation need planning
- Glossy, more uniform appearance
- A familiar option for kitchen walls
- Not ruled out by this renovation
Plan the whole palette
A patterned backsplash works best when considered alongside the room around it.
Consider warm wood, complementary countertop stone and rustic-finish hardware.
Ask a supplier or qualified installer about suitability, cleaning and maintenance.
Account for materials and installation before choosing a permanent backsplash.
A Warmer Alternative to Subway Tile
The renovation shows how a backsplash can help set the mood of a kitchen, rather than functioning only as a practical surface behind a sink or stove. In the Gaineses’ design, the ivory-and-brown artisan tile contributes texture and pattern while reinforcing the room’s connection to its surroundings. That approach may appeal to homeowners who want a more personal, less standardized look.
Handmade and artisan-style tiles are associated with visible variation and a crafted finish. Those qualities can suit a lived-in, layered interior, but they also require homeowners to weigh appearance against cost, availability and installation. The example is a specific design choice in a television renovation, not evidence that subway tile has universally fallen out of favor or that every kitchen benefits from a patterned backsplash.
For readers considering a similar update, the practical takeaway is to plan the tile alongside the rest of the room. The supplied design guidance recommends pairing artisan tile with warm wood, complementary countertop stone and rustic-finish hardware. Creamy hues and personal touches, such as a small artwork or retro-looking appliance, can help the backsplash feel integrated rather than applied as a trend on its own.
Products Worth Considering

Dyson Airwrap i.d. Multi-Styler with Bluetooth Connectivity

Samsung 65-Inch 4K OLED Smart TV with Dolby Atmos, 120Hz Refresh Rate, and Amber Protection Bundle

Roborock Q7 L5 Robot Vacuum and Mop Combo, 8,000 Pa Suction
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Inside the Colorado Mountain Makeover
The project appears in Fixer Upper: Colorado Mountain House—Part 2. According to the Magnolia blog, the design team moved away from its familiar Texas setting and sought a style responsive to the Colorado home. Its stated aim was to blend the interiors with the Rocky Mountain surroundings through color, texture and pattern.
The tile’s Delft-inspired geometry and chocolate palette serve that direction in a compact kitchen zone. The episode’s hot cocoa and coffee bar also gives the warm brown pattern a clear role in the room’s visual theme. The supplied material describes artisan tiles as valued for craftsmanship, imperfections and warmth; those are design considerations, not a claim that all handmade tiles have the same finish or performance.
For homeowners who like the look, the material offers two lower-commitment routes: a peel-and-stick product identified as Red Barrel Studio’s Brooklyn Delft Ivy peel-and-stick wallpaper, or hand-decorated white tiles. The latter approach, described as an activity shared by creatives such as Macey Merlak, involves porcelain paint and baking tiles before installing them. It calls for skill, and the supplied material does not provide product-specific instructions or safety guidance.
““specifically blend with the surroundings””
— Magnolia blog post about the Colorado renovation
Costs and Installation Details
The supplied material does not state the tile’s price, the quantity installed, the project’s total backsplash cost or the precise installation method. It says backsplash installation can average up to $1,500, but does not specify the market, project size, time period or comparison basis for that figure. Handcrafted tiles can add expense, though the amount will depend on the product and installation.
It is also unclear whether the tile selection represents a broader shift in the Gaineses’ work or a choice specific to this Colorado home. The claim that subway tile has lost its appeal is presented as a design judgment, not as a measured industry trend. No sales data, homeowner survey or expert assessment is provided to establish how widely preferences have changed.
The DIY approach described also leaves practical questions unanswered, including whether a particular tile and paint are suitable for oven curing, how the finished tiles should be sealed, and what installation methods are appropriate for a backsplash. Homeowners should check product directions and local requirements before attempting the work.
Planning a Similar Backsplash
The episode and Magnolia blog provide the available details about the Gaineses’ design decision; no additional project announcement or follow-up date is specified. Readers seeking the look can compare artisan tiles with less permanent peel-and-stick alternatives, then check product specifications, total material costs and installation needs before choosing.
For a permanent installation, homeowners can ask tile suppliers or qualified installers about suitable materials, cleaning and maintenance, and whether the chosen product works in the intended location. Anyone considering painted tiles should follow the maker’s instructions for paint and tile and avoid assuming that a social-media demonstration is a complete installation guide. The next practical step is to assess the backsplash as part of the whole kitchen palette, including cabinets, counters, lighting and hardware.
Key Questions
What backsplash tile did Joanna Gaines use?
The Colorado home’s game-room kitchen features Tiles of Ezra Amano Caja in chocolate, a patterned clay tile with an ivory base and light-brown geometric accents.
Where did the tile appear?
It was installed in the game-room kitchen area of the Colorado mountain home featured in Fixer Upper: Colorado Mountain House—Part 2, including near a hot cocoa and coffee bar.
Why did the Gaineses choose this style?
The Magnolia blog says the design was intended to blend with the Rocky Mountain surroundings. The couple described the overall direction as European cottage-inspired, with colors, textures and patterns chosen for a cozy feel.
Is artisan tile more expensive than subway tile?
The supplied material says handcrafted tiles can add to backsplash costs, but it does not give a direct price comparison for these products. Total costs vary with tile price, project size and installation.
What are alternatives to buying handmade tiles?
The article describes a peel-and-stick option and a DIY approach using white tiles and porcelain paint. Painted tiles require appropriate products and careful attention to curing and installation instructions.
Source: hunker.com
