TL;DR
Millions of Americans voted to ban gestation crates for pigs in California and Massachusetts. Congress is now considering legislation, included in the Farm Bill, that could reverse these laws. The industry and animal advocates are at odds over the move, which could affect animal welfare and pork trade.
Congress is advancing legislation that aims to nullify California and Massachusetts laws banning the use of gestation crates for pigs, despite widespread public support for animal welfare reforms. The move could significantly impact efforts to improve conditions for millions of pigs raised in confinement, and is part of the ongoing political battle over animal rights and agricultural industry interests.
Most of America’s 6 million female breeding pigs are confined in gestation crates, which prevent them from turning around and cause significant stress and suffering, according to animal welfare experts. California and Massachusetts voters approved laws in 2018 and 2020 respectively, banning the use of these crates and the sale of pork from farms that use them. Despite legal challenges from the pork industry, courts have upheld these laws, including a 2023 Supreme Court decision affirming California’s law as constitutional.
However, the industry has lobbied Congress for over a decade to pass federal legislation that would invalidate these state laws. The latest effort, called the Save Our Bacon Act, was included in the House Farm Bill passed in April 2025. This legislation aims to preempt state laws by establishing a federal standard that allows the continued use of gestation crates, effectively reversing the recent state-level reforms.
Industry groups like Triumph Foods and the National Pork Producers Council argue that the laws violate the dormant commerce clause, which restricts states from enacting laws that unfairly burden interstate commerce. Conversely, animal advocates and many farmers who have transitioned to group housing say the legislation undermines efforts to improve animal welfare and reflects industry resistance to change.
Why It Matters
This development is significant because it could roll back popular and legally upheld animal welfare laws in California and Massachusetts, which have influenced other states and industry practices. If the federal legislation passes, it could lead to a resurgence of confinement practices that many consider inhumane, affecting millions of pigs and setting a precedent for federal interference in state-level animal protections. The move also highlights ongoing tensions between industry interests, animal rights advocates, and consumers demanding more humane farming practices.
Homey Pet 3 Levels Chinchilla Ferret Pet Crate Small Animals Cages for Rat, Hamster, Guinea Pig, Squirrel, Include Caster Tray and Urine Guard (Black)
Size: 25"L x 17"W x 38"H, bar spacing: 0.7", color: black
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Background
Since the early 2000s, several states have enacted laws to improve pig welfare by banning or restricting the use of gestation crates. California and Massachusetts were among the first to do so through ballot initiatives supported by public votes with large majorities. The pork industry has challenged these laws in courts, but courts have generally upheld them, including a 2023 Supreme Court ruling in favor of California.
Despite legal defeats, industry groups have continued efforts to pass federal legislation to preempt state laws, arguing that such laws disrupt interstate commerce and impose unfair burdens on producers. The current legislative push is part of the broader debate over animal welfare versus industry regulation, with the Farm Bill serving as the legislative vehicle.
“A vote for the farm bill is a vote to cage an animal that can’t walk or turn around.”
— Brent Hershey, hog farmer
“Gestation crates are akin to forcing a human to live in an airline seat.”
— Animal welfare scientist Temple Grandin
Management and Welfare of Farm Animals: The UFAW Farm Handbook (UFAW Animal Welfare)
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
What Remains Unclear
It remains unclear whether the Senate will approve the legislation as included in the House Farm Bill, or if amendments will be made. The political dynamics and lobbying efforts could influence the final outcome, and legal challenges may continue if the legislation becomes law.
KJAOYU 304 Stainless Steel Pig Catcher – Efficient Labor Saving Tool for Pig Control and Management in Farming – Ideal for Farmers and Livestock Handlers
Stainless Steel Construction: Crafted from premium 304 stainless steel, this pig catcher is built for durability and reliability,…
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
What’s Next
The Senate is expected to debate and vote on the Farm Bill in the coming weeks. If approved, the legislation will go to the President for signing. Further legal challenges or state-level actions could also follow, depending on the final legislative outcome and implementation details.
Farm Hounds – Pork Kidney – Premium Natural Jerky for Dogs – Made from 100% Humanely Raised Pork- Organ Treats – Great for Training & Treats – No Added Fillers – Made in USA – 4oz -1 Pack
PORK KIDNEY – Our Pork Kidney organ treats are humanely-raised pork jerky treats for dogs that all breeds,…
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Key Questions
What are gestation crates and why are they controversial?
Gestation crates are small enclosures that confine pregnant pigs, preventing them from turning around. Many animal welfare advocates consider them inhumane due to the stress and suffering they cause.
Why are some states banning gestation crates?
States like California and Massachusetts have banned their use through voter-approved laws to improve animal welfare and reduce cruelty in pig farming.
What is the Save Our Bacon Act?
It is federal legislation aimed at nullifying state laws banning gestation crates, allowing the pork industry to continue confining pigs in such crates nationwide.
How might this legislation affect pig welfare?
If passed, it could lead to a resurgence of confinement practices considered inhumane by many animal advocates, reversing recent progress in animal welfare laws.
